Instructions
This is a peer evaluation sheet. Students are required to evaluate three sites chosen for you to evaluate by your instructor. Use the peer evaluation marking sheet to record the results for three sites. Students should indicate on their marking sheet whether a 1,2,3, or 4 has been achieved for each question given here.
Design of Web site Questions - Communication (out of 12, weight of 3)
1. Navigating Between Pages
1. There was difficulty navigating. ( For example it was not possible to link back to a home page)
2. The majority of the site was easy to navigate, however one or more areas was difficult.
3. The site was easy to navigate. I could always get back to the home page readily.
4. The site used frames or some other consistent organization such as a web map to make it very easy to navigate.
2. Size, Layout and Navigation on Pages
1. There were problems navigating on some pages, perhaps there is too much content on a single page.
2. All pages worked well. It was relatively easy to find the required information on all pages
3. The home page was quick to load without to many complicated graphics.
4. The pages were very well organized. Looking through pages kept your interest and you found information easily.
3. Interest, Appropriateness
1. I felt that the page was not professional or appropriate for the subject matter.
2. Some areas of the web site were appropriate but there was one or more areas which were inappropriate.
3. Graphics were used effectively in a professional manner manner suitable for the subject matter.
4. The site was professional, used graphics appropriately and links were included to appropriate external sites.
Research & Content Questions - Knowledge (out of 28, weight of 7)
4. Examples of Employers
1. Provided an example of an employer.
2. Provided an example of an employer in the private sector and in the public sector.
3. Provided an example of an employer in the public sector and the private sector as well as an indication whether this job could be conducted as an entrepreneur.
4. Provided an example of an employer in the public sector and the private sector as well as an indication whether this job could be conducted as an entrepreneur. A discussion or points was included stating the advantages and disadvantages of each employment option.
5. Sample Job Description
1. There is a title of a job.
2. There is a job description which conveys something about the job.
3. Web pages include at least one job description indicating the tasks, activities and/or responsibilities of the job.
4. Web pages includes more than one job description indicating the tasks, activities and responsibilities of the job and indicates the source of the job description.
6. Education Required
1. The web page includes some indication of education required.
2. Education listed is complete except it does not include one of the following; education requirements for the job, acceptance requirements to the program, and/or work experience required.
3. Web pages include the education requirement for the job, an the requirements to be accepted to the educational program. Any work experience required for qualification in the job is included if required.
4. Web pages include the education requirement for the job, an the requirements to be accepted to the educational program. Any work experience required for qualification in the job is included if required. Links to educational resources are included.
7. Salary
1. The salary is mentioned.
2. A typical starting salary and average salary is included.
3. A good idea of the salary range which can be expected is in the web page. The source of this information is included. Typical benefits are mentioned.
4. The factors which can effect the salary within that range are included.
8. Good & Bad Points of Career
1. Good and/or bad points of the career are mentioned.
2. Advantages and/or disadvantages of the career are clearly presented.
3. There is some discussion as to the good and bad points of work in this career. This is presented in such a way as to not judge the career but rather present the pro’s and con’s.
4. The web page indicates which personal characteristics would be beneficial to this career or what type of person would enjoy this career the most.
9. Future Prospects
1. Future prospects are mentioned.
2. There is a general prediction as to whether this job will be decline, sustained or increased demand in the future.
3. There is a general prediction as to whether this job will be decline, sustained or increased demand in the future. There is some justification of the reason for this prediction.
4. A discussion of the factors which affect the growth of this profession is included. Perhaps several predictions are included depending on the outcome of the factors.
10. Testimonials, Interviews & Comments
1. A comment is included.
2. There is some comment or quote from someone in the field, or from an employer advertising for the job.
3. There is some comment or quote from someone in the field, or from an employer advertising for the job. The source of the information is included.
4. You get a pretty clear indication of what the career is like, based on the comments, testimonials or interviews in the site.